Tanner-Ibbotson Logo


1109 Commons Avenue      Cortland, NY 13045    607.756.7531

Your Local Independent
Insurance Agency


We recognize that every business is unique. We have the experience to handle businesses of any size. We want to meet with you so that we can assess your insurance needs. We can offer tailored insurance solutions for the following lines of business:

Click here if you would like to be contacted to set an appointment.

 Meet the Staff:

Eric Mertz  

Eric Mertz- President

Eric joined Tanner-Ibbotson in 1994. He worked in insurance since 1989.  Eric became majority owner and President of Tanner-Ibbotson in 2012.  In additon to overseeing the entire operation, Eric is actively involved in the Commercial Lines Department.

brian Toglia  

Brian Toglia- Vice President

Brian joined Tanner-Ibbotson in 2005. He became minority owner and Vice-President of Tanner-Ibbotson in 2012.  Brian is actively involved in the Commercial Lines Department. 

Anne Fitzgerald  

Anne Fitzgerald- Commercial Lines Service

Anne joined Tanner-Ibbotson in 2001. She has worked in insurance since 1984.  Anne is a licensed agent and holds the CISR Insurance designation.  She provides a high level of customer service to Commercial Lines Clients.

Jodi Poole  

Jody Poole- Commercial Lines Service

Jody joined Tanner-Ibbotson in October of 2013.  She holds a CIC & CISR Insurance Designation. Jody has worked in insurance since 1998. She handles new business sales and service.

Aaron Craig  

Aaron Craig- Personal Lines Sales

Aaron is the newest addition to Tanner-Ibbotson. He started in July of 2014. He has a strong a customer service background and is a licensed agent for Life and Health Insurance.


Trusted Choice
  Pledge of Performance

Companies Represented   Terms of Use

Copyright © 2011-15 Tanner-Ibbotson, Inc. All Rights Reserved.
1109 Commons Ave., Cortland, NY 13045
Phone: (607) 756-7531 Fax: (607) 753-3050


Site by GNC